Top Picks

Welcome to the Hall of Fame of Cook Season. Our Top Picks page features the recipes that our community loves the most and that our editors cook on repeat. These aren't just good recipes; they are the tried-and-true staples that guarantee a delicious meal every time. From the ultimate comfort food classics to the most popular quick dinner ideas, these dishes have earned their spot at the top through 5-star ratings and rave reviews.

318 results in this collection. Page 4 of 36

Our Top Picks

Shortbread cookies recipe
Shortbread cookies recipe

This classic shortbread cookies recipe is the only one you’ll ever need to achieve that perfect, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Hailing from...

Pioneer pecan pie
Pioneer pecan pie

This classic Pioneer pecan pie recipe has been a cherished part of my family’s holiday table for as long as...

Lemon shortbread cookies
Lemon shortbread cookies

These lemon shortbread cookies are my absolute go-to recipe for a treat that feels both simple and incredibly special. They...

Eggplant recipe
Eggplant recipe

This classic eggplant recipe, known as Baingan Bharta, is one of those dishes that feels like home. It’s a staple...

Too Much Chocolate Cake
Too Much Chocolate Cake

This Too Much Chocolate Cake absolutely earns its bold name and delivers an unforgettable chocolate experience that’s become my go-to...

Brie Apple Pastries
Brie Apple Pastries

Brie Apple Pastries have become my go-to effortless appetizer because they deliver a taste experience that feels gourmet. This French-inspired...

Crockpot Breakfast Casserole
Crockpot Breakfast Casserole

Your search for the perfect crowd-pleasing morning meal ends with this Set-It-and-Forget-It Crockpot Breakfast Casserole. Born from the need for...

Blackberry Goat Cheese Twists
Blackberry Goat Cheese Twists

These Blackberry Goat Cheese Twists are the kind of effortless appetizer that makes you look like a pastry pro without...

Gumdrop Punch
Gumdrop Punch

Gumdrop Punch is that vibrant, nostalgic drink that always steals the show at my holiday parties. This American classic transforms...