Top Picks

Welcome to the Hall of Fame of Cook Season. Our Top Picks page features the recipes that our community loves the most and that our editors cook on repeat. These aren't just good recipes; they are the tried-and-true staples that guarantee a delicious meal every time. From the ultimate comfort food classics to the most popular quick dinner ideas, these dishes have earned their spot at the top through 5-star ratings and rave reviews.

318 results in this collection. Page 1 of 36

Our Top Picks

3 ingredient peanut butter cookies
3 ingredient peanut butter cookies

This classic recipe for 3 ingredient peanut butter cookies is the perfect starting point for the ultimate homemade treat. We...

Gumdrop Punch
Gumdrop Punch

Gumdrop Punch is that vibrant, nostalgic drink that always steals the show at my holiday parties. This American classic transforms...

Easy French Toast Casserole
Easy French Toast Casserole

This Overnight Easy French Toast Casserole is the ultimate solution for a stress-free, spectacular breakfast or brunch. It captures all...

Shortbread cookies recipe
Shortbread cookies recipe

This classic shortbread cookies recipe is the only one you’ll ever need to achieve that perfect, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Hailing from...

Black Eyed Pea Soup
Black Eyed Pea Soup

This hearty Southern-style Black Eyed Pea Soup simmers with smoky ham and a classic mix of vegetables for a bowl...

Homemade Mango Iced Tea
Homemade Mango Iced Tea

Homemade Mango Iced Tea is my absolute go-to when I need a refreshing escape from the summer heat. This vibrant...

Chocolate Glazed Donuts
Chocolate Glazed Donuts

These Chocolate Glazed Donuts are the ultimate weekend baking project, delivering that nostalgic bakery experience right in your kitchen. I’ve...

Street Corn Chicken Bowl
Street Corn Chicken Bowl

These Street Corn Chicken Bowls capture the incredible energy of Mexican street food with zero fuss. Imagine juicy grilled chicken...

No bake cheesecake recipe
No bake cheesecake recipe

This is the classic, foolproof no bake cheesecake recipe you’ve been searching for. It delivers a rich, tangy, and incredibly...