Top Picks

Welcome to the Hall of Fame of Cook Season. Our Top Picks page features the recipes that our community loves the most and that our editors cook on repeat. These aren't just good recipes; they are the tried-and-true staples that guarantee a delicious meal every time. From the ultimate comfort food classics to the most popular quick dinner ideas, these dishes have earned their spot at the top through 5-star ratings and rave reviews.

318 results in this collection. Page 25 of 36

Our Top Picks

Christmas Crock Pot Candy
Christmas Crock Pot Candy

This Christmas Crock Pot Candy is the ultimate holiday game-changer, saving you time and stress during the busiest season. It’s...

Vegan Polenta
Vegan Polenta

This creamy vegan polenta has become my go-to weeknight comfort food, proving that plant-based dishes can be every bit as...

Easy brownie recipe
Easy brownie recipe

This is the ultimate easy brownie recipe that has become my absolute go-to for any occasion that calls for a...

Turkey casserole
Turkey casserole

This turkey casserole is the quintessential American comfort food, born from the thrifty tradition of using up holiday leftovers in...

Pearl’s Green Bean Casserole
Pearl’s Green Bean Casserole

Pearl’s Green Bean Casserole has been the ultimate holiday side dish in my family for generations. This from-scratch American recipe...

Cheesy Broccoli Baked Potatoes
Cheesy Broccoli Baked Potatoes

These Cheesy Broccoli Baked Potatoes are my ultimate weeknight lifesaver, a humble yet incredibly satisfying American comfort food classic. They...

Cherry Smoothie
Cherry Smoothie

This cherry smoothie has been my morning ritual for years, blending sweet and tart flavors into a vibrant drink. As...

Chocolate Cookie Mix in a Jar
Chocolate Cookie Mix in a Jar

This Chocolate Cookie Mix in a Jar is my absolute favorite gift to give during the holidays because it’s thoughtful,...

Peppermint Patties
Peppermint Patties

These homemade Peppermint Patties deliver that classic, cool mint flavor you love, wrapped in a satisfyingly crisp chocolate shell. There’s...